Best Carpet Reddit Recommendations: Top 7 Picks

Are you in search of the perfect carpet for your home? Look no further than Reddit, the internet’s treasure trove of knowledge and recommendations. In this article, we will dive into the world of carpets …

best carpet reddit

Are you in search of the perfect carpet for your home? Look no further than Reddit, the internet’s treasure trove of knowledge and recommendations. In this article, we will dive into the world of carpets and explore the best carpet Reddit recommendations have to offer.

From the best wool carpet Reddit advice to triexta carpet, we’ll cover it all to help you make an informed decision.

So, let’s unravel the secrets of the Reddit community and discover the top seven carpets that will transform your living space.

Best Wool Carpet Reddit Advice

When it comes to elegance and natural beauty, wool carpets reign supreme.

Reddit users appreciate the timeless appeal and numerous benefits that wool brings to the table. From its soft texture to its durability, wool carpets are a popular choice among homeowners seeking a touch of luxury.

Wool carpet Reddit discussion

Here are some main points Reddit users share about wool rugs and carpets:

CommentKey Points
You can find tribal or Tibetan wool rugs at your budget. Indian or Pakistani rugs cost 50% more. Genuine Persian rugs are 100% more expensive. Look for trustworthy local rug merchants and negotiate. Authentic wool rugs are more durable and beautiful than machine-made ones.Price ranges for different types of wool rugs. Importance of finding trustworthy sellers.
Recommends finding a local store for wool rugs. No specific brand names were mentioned. Hand-knotted rugs are considered best.Humorous suggestion for a BIFL wool rug alternative.
Recommends finding a local store for wool rugs. No specific brand names were mentioned. Hand-knotted rugs are considered best.Emphasizes the need to find a local store and mentions the preference for hand-knotted rugs.
Recommends a fair trade flat-woven wool rug from Import charges apply.Suggests purchasing a fair trade wool rug from an online store.
Suggests buying a cheap rug and adding carpet padding underneath.Recommends adding carpet padding to a cheap rug for better comfort.
States that wool wears well and that higher quality carpets are typically made of wool. Suggests nylon as a good substitute. Advises against polypropylene.Highlights the benefits of modern synthetic carpets compared to wool.
Recommends wool carpet for areas near fireplaces due to its fire resistance. Suggests choosing a color that hides stains.Suggests using wool carpet near fireplaces due to its fire resistance and recommends stain-hiding colors.
Shares positive experience with wool carpet’s durability and cleaning. Mentions the high price.Personal experience with wool carpet’s durability and cleaning ability. Acknowledges the high price.
Provides pros and cons of wool carpet, including durability, sustainability, hypoallergenic properties, fire resistance, easy maintenance, cost, and susceptibility to stains and mold.Describes wool as durable and high-quality. Suggests nylon as an alternative.
Advises against choosing a light-colored wool carpet if the soil outside is clay-based.Warns against light-colored wool carpets in areas with clay soil.
Expresses skepticism about the cost and longevity of wool carpets compared to synthetic options.Expresses doubt about the cost-effectiveness of wool carpets and suggests synthetic alternatives.
Advises finding a balance between personal preference and what would be attractive to potential buyers if selling the home. Recommends avoiding high-maintenance options.Suggests considering future resale value and avoiding high-maintenance choices.
Shares limited experience with wool carpet and suggests it may be beneficial for those with allergies.Shares personal experience with wool carpet and suggests it may be suitable for people with allergies.
Provides a comprehensive list of the pros and cons of wool carpet. Mentions price, maintenance, and potential issues with stains and mold.Provides a comprehensive list of the pros and cons of wool carpets. Mentions price, maintenance, and potential issues with stains and mold.

However, selecting the right wool carpet can be overwhelming due to the wide range of options available.

Here are more helpful suggestions and experiences with wool rugs on price, pros and cons from Reddit users:

BIFL wool rugs start at 4 digits and are generally made by humans. Recommend finding a rug that fits your budget, size, and aesthetic.
Budget around $1500 for semi-interesting options. Will save more to meet all requirements.
Quality synthetic rugs also run in the thousands.
Looking for something similar but doesn’t have a high budget. Considering checking thrift stores.
Suggests checking out Hook and Loom or Revival for rug options.
Suggests getting a remnant of wool wall-to-wall carpet cut to any size and having the edges bound.
Find a local place that sells rugs made by humans.
Good quality wool can last decades with basic care. Recommends wool or 80% wool 20% nylon blend.
Suggests getting a remnant of wool wall-to-wall carpet cut to any size and have the edges bound.
Wool rugs are recommended. Secondhand options and brands like Karastan offer less expensive alternatives.
Advises avoiding synthetic rugs due to health concerns and suggests looking for organic cotton or wool options.
Ended up choosing a wool rug and recommends reading a helpful rug-buying guide.
Prefers Ruggable due to ease of cleaning with pets and children.
Emphasizes the importance of considering style, use case, and the cost of cleaning when choosing a rug.
Look for woven rugs instead of fuzzy carpet-like rugs for durability.
Asks about the cleaning method and type of rug preferred.
Suggests looking for rugs made with natural fibers like cotton, wool, and silk.
Wishes good luck and mentions the importance of a nice rug in tying a room together.
Asks what ties the room together.

To help you narrow down your search, Reddit users have shared their top picks based on personal experiences and expertise. Here are some best wool carpet Reddit recommendations to guide you:

#1 Karastan Rug (high-end option)

Karastan rugs are high-quality, machine-made rugs that are known for their beauty, durability, and craftsmanship.

They are produced by the Karastan brand, which has a long-standing reputation for creating exquisite rugs.

Karastan rugs are made using advanced weaving techniques and premium materials, resulting in rugs that closely resemble handmade rugs. They are primarily made from wool, although some rugs incorporate other fibers such as nylon or silk.

The brand is recognized for its attention to detail, intricate designs, and use of vibrant colors.

One of the notable features of Karastan rugs is their intricate patterns and designs. Many of these designs are inspired by traditional Oriental and Persian rug motifs, as well as other global influences.

These rugs can be found in various styles, including traditional, transitional, and contemporary, offering a wide range of options to suit different tastes and interior design preferences.

wool karastan carpet
Wool Karastan carpet

In addition to their visual appeal, Karastan rugs are highly regarded for their durability. They are crafted using a combination of traditional weaving techniques and modern technology, resulting in rugs that can withstand heavy foot traffic and maintain their beauty over time.

Overall, Karastan rugs are considered a symbol of luxury and elegance in the world of rugs. They are often sought after by homeowners and interior designers who appreciate the combination of artistry, quality, and durability that these rugs offer.

#2 Artistic Weavers Rugs

Artistic Weavers rugs are known for their quality craftsmanship and unique designs.

Here are some features commonly associated with Artistic Weavers rugs:

  1. Materials: Artistic Weavers rugs are made using various high-quality materials, including wool, silk, jute, and synthetic fibers. Wool is a popular choice due to its durability, softness, and natural stain resistance.
  2. Intricate Designs: Artistic Weavers rugs feature intricate and visually captivating designs. These designs can range from traditional motifs to contemporary patterns, often incorporating geometric shapes, floral elements, or abstract compositions.
  3. Color Variations: Artistic Weavers rugs offer a wide range of color options, allowing you to find a rug that complements your space and personal style. Vibrant hues, subtle neutrals, and various shades in between are commonly found in their collections.
  4. Texture and Pile Height: Depending on the design and intended use, Artistic Weavers rugs can have different pile heights and textures. Some rugs have a plush and luxurious feel with a higher pile, while others have a low pile or a textured surface that adds dimension and interest to the design.
  5. Durability: Artistic Weavers rugs are crafted to be durable and long-lasting. The high-quality materials and meticulous construction techniques ensure that the rugs can withstand regular foot traffic and maintain their appearance over time.
artistic weavers rugs reviews
Wool Artistic Weavers rugs

It’s important to note that specific features may vary across different collections and rug designs offered by Artistic Weavers.

Reddit Picks: What is the Nicest Type of Carpet?

When it comes to choosing the nicest type of carpet, Reddit users have varied opinions.

Each individual’s preference may depend on factors such as lifestyle, budget, and personal style.

However, certain types of carpets consistently receive praise for their overall appeal and quality.

Let’s explore the Reddit picks for the nicest type of carpet:

  1. Nylon: Known for its durability and stain resistance, nylon carpets are a popular choice among homeowners. Their ability to withstand heavy foot traffic while maintaining their beauty makes them a top contender for the nicest carpet.
  2. Wool: As mentioned earlier, wool carpets offer a touch of luxury and natural beauty. With their softness and timeless appeal, they are often considered among the nicest options available.
  3. Triexta carpet: This relatively new carpet fiber has gained popularity due to its exceptional durability and stain resistance. It offers a soft feel underfoot while being resistant to spills and stains, making it an attractive choice for those seeking both beauty and practicality.

Here additional comments Reddit users give about choosing the nicest type of carpet or rug:

Cheap carpet stains easily, isn’t soft, and has a lower pile.
Top-tier nylon carpet can deteriorate quickly.
Good carpet costs around $5+ per sqft and lasts for years.
Top-tier nylon carpets can deteriorate quickly.
Loop carpets can last for years, and wholesale prices are beneficial.
Cheap carpet stains easily, isn’t soft and has a lower pile.
High-quality carpet with a high-end pad is worth the investment.
The new high-quality carpet is resistant to stains and easy to clean.
Basic carpet is chosen due to kids’ potential for stains.
Flippers use cheap and low-quality carpets in their renovations.
Referring to Dalton, a city known for carpet manufacturing.
Flippers use cheap and low-quality carpet in their renovations.
Good quality carpet starts around $5/sqft.
Carpet priced at $5/sqft or more is likely to be good quality.
Triexta carpet with memory foam pads is dense, soft, and high-pile.

#3 Mohawk Home rugs

Mohawk Home rugs are known for their exceptional quality and style.

Here are some key features that make them stand out:

  1. Premium Materials: Mohawk Home rugs are crafted using high-quality materials, including soft and durable fibers like nylon, polyester, and polypropylene. These materials ensure that the rugs are not only comfortable but also resistant to stains, fading, and wear.
  2. Stylish Designs: Mohawk Home offers a wide range of stylish designs to suit any decor and personal taste. From traditional and floral patterns to modern and abstract motifs, there’s a rug for every style preference. You can find rugs that add a pop of color to a room or ones that provide a more subtle and understated look.
  3. Easy Maintenance: Mohawk Home rugs are designed with convenience in mind. They are typically easy to clean and maintain, thanks to their stain-resistant properties. This means that spills and accidents can be easily addressed, making the rugs suitable for high-traffic areas or homes with children and pets.
  4. Durability: Mohawk Home rugs are built to last. The combination of quality materials, expert craftsmanship, and rigorous testing ensures that these rugs can withstand everyday use and maintain their appearance over time.

These features make them an excellent choice for enhancing the beauty and functionality of any space in your home.

#4 Artistic Weavers Odelia vintage rug

Another popular carpet option is the Odelia vintage rugs from the already mentioned Artistic Weavers brand.

artistic weavers odelia vintage bohemian area rug
Artistic Weavers Odelia vintage bohemian area rug

Reddit Picks: What is the Best Most Durable Carpet?

Durability is a crucial factor to consider when choosing a carpet that can withstand the test of time.

Reddit users have shared their experiences and recommendations for the most durable carpets available.

Here are some main theses from Reddit users about strength and longevity:

Nylon rugs wear better than polyester rugs. Polyester rugs show signs of wear in higher traffic areas within a year.
Recommends nylon rugs for better resiliency compared to polyester rugs. Shares an analogy of a plastic pop bottle to explain the difference.
Points out that nylon is also a type of plastic, making the analogy less accurate. Explains that comparing carpets is difficult due to various factors like density, twist, and style.
Suggests upgrading the underlay to a higher quality, around 10 lb, to enhance carpet durability.
Recommends a 32 oz felt pad as a durable option that helps prevent wrinkles, particularly suitable for berber carpets.
Advises getting the best carpet pad possible to increase the lifespan of the carpets.
Recommends Mohawk’s SmartCushion for high-quality carpet padding. Suggests choosing carpets made of nylon yarn.
Explains that higher face weight and twist count are generally indicators of better carpet quality. Recommends choosing carpets made by reputable manufacturers like Mohawk, DuPont, or Stainmaster.
Clarifies that the emphasis is on getting the best pad within one’s budget, not necessarily the most expensive one.
Acknowledges the clarification and recommends avoiding cheap pads.
Agrees with the importance of a quality pad and suggests considering personal preferences for texture, thickness, and material. Mentions the option of Scotchgard for added protection.

#5 Nylon carpets for living room

nylon carpets
Nylon carpets for living room

Reddit Picks: What’s the Most Luxurious Carpet?

If you’re seeking the utmost luxury under your feet, Reddit has got you covered. The community has identified some truly lavish carpets that add a touch of opulence to any space.

  1. Silk: For unparalleled luxury, silk carpets are a top choice. With their smooth texture and shimmering appearance, they exude elegance and sophistication.
  2. High-end Wool: While wool carpets were previously mentioned for their natural beauty, high-end wool carpets take it to the next level. These premium options offer exceptional craftsmanship and luxurious finishes that elevate the overall aesthetic of a room.
  3. Plush and Shag: Plush and shag carpets, made from various materials, provide a sumptuously soft and cozy feel. Their deep pile adds depth and comfort, creating a luxurious atmosphere in any space.

Here are some Reddit comments on luxurious carpets:

If you’re living in a place for 5-10 years, get whatever you want, make your house comfortable for how you want to live.Personal preference and comfort are important factors.
Carpet is preferred for its feel and texture, but cost depends on the type chosen.Carpet can be expensive, but plush carpets always look good.
If you plan to stay less than 10 years, consider LVP (Luxury Vinyl Plank) and use large area rugs on top if you still want the feel of carpet.LVP is a good option for easy cleaning and cost-effective installation.
Mid-grade nylon carpet can look good for ten years if well maintained.Carpet can last long if not subjected to excessive wear and tear.
Trends come and go, choose what you like. Carpet is cozy and absorbs noise, while LVP is suitable for high traffic areas.Different floor types suit different rooms better.
Tile floors are preferred for restrooms due to hygiene concerns with carpets.Carpet is not recommended for bathrooms due to cleanliness issues.
LVP is easier to clean and maintain, and it can be quieter with appropriate underlay.LVP is quieter than hardwood due to cushioned underlay.
Consider the wear layer thickness when selecting LVP for better scratch resistance.Thicker wear layers are recommended for better durability.
Dogs can cause scratches, so nail trimming and well-trained behavior are important.Dogs’ scratches can be controlled with proper care and training.
LVP is preferred over carpets due to easier maintenance and cleanliness.LVP is easier to maintain and does not accumulate dirt and hair like carpets.
Consider budget and lifestyle when choosing flooring.Choose flooring that suits your budget and lifestyle.

#6 Safavieh Samarkand rug

Safavieh carpets and rugs are renowned for their exquisite craftsmanship and timeless designs.

Here are some key features that set them apart:

  1. Artistic Elegance: Safavieh rugs are known for their artistic elegance, often incorporating intricate patterns, captivating motifs, and rich color palettes. Whether you’re looking for a traditional Oriental rug or a contemporary abstract design, Safavieh offers a wide range of styles to suit different tastes and interior decor.
  2. High-Quality Materials: Safavieh uses premium materials to ensure durability and comfort. Their rugs are crafted from natural fibers like wool, silk, and cotton, as well as synthetic materials like polypropylene. This diverse selection of materials allows you to choose a rug that fits your preferences for texture, softness, and maintenance requirements.
  3. Handmade Craftsmanship: Many Safavieh rugs are handcrafted by skilled artisans using traditional weaving techniques. Each rug tells a story of meticulous craftsmanship and attention to detail. These handmade rugs often possess a unique character and charm that can only be achieved through the artisan’s skillful hands.
  4. Luxurious Texture: Safavieh rugs are renowned for their luxurious texture. Whether it’s the softness of a wool rug or the smoothness of a silk rug, these textures add a touch of opulence to your floors and provide a comfortable surface to walk on.
  5. Easy Maintenance: Safavieh understands the importance of convenience in rug care. Many of their rugs are designed to be low-maintenance, resistant to stains, and easy to clean. This makes them ideal for busy households or high-traffic areas where spills and accidents are more likely to occur.
  6. Trusted Brand: Safavieh is a trusted brand with a long-standing reputation for excellence in the rug industry. With decades of experience, they consistently deliver high-quality products that meet the expectations of customers worldwide.
  7. Wide Availability: Safavieh rugs are widely available, both online and in retail stores. This accessibility makes it easier for customers to explore their extensive collection, compare options, and find the perfect rug for their homes.
safavieh samarkand rug
Safavieh Samarkand rug

In summary, with Safavieh, you can bring a touch of timeless beauty and sophistication to your living space.

Reddit Picks: What Type of Carpet Stays the Cleanest?

Maintaining a clean and fresh carpet is a priority for many homeowners. Reddit users have shared their experiences with carpets that are easy to clean and resist stains.

To this type of carpet and rugs belong:

  1. Stain-Resistant Nylon: Nylon carpets with built-in stain resistance are highly recommended for their easy maintenance. Spills and accidents can be swiftly cleaned up without leaving a lasting mark, making them ideal for families with children or pets.
  2. Solution-Dyed Polyester: Polyester carpets that are solution-dyed, meaning the color is added during the manufacturing process, are known for their excellent stain resistance. The color penetrates the entire fiber, making it less likely to fade or stain.
  3. Triexta: Once again, triexta stands out as a fiber that is not only durable but also resistant to stains. It offers excellent cleanability, ensuring that your carpet stays looking fresh even after accidental spills.

Here are the Reddit comments on stain-resistant carpets:

Suggests going with triexta or PET or nylon carpets. Recommends using a memory foam cushion.
The carpet cleaner/repair technician recommends good quality nylon as the best option. Expresses doubts about triexta’s long-term quality. Mentions Karastan as an excellent option. Emphasizes the importance of maintenance and a good pad.
The carpet cleaner/repair technician recommends good-quality nylon as the best option. Expresses doubts about triexta’s long-term quality. Mentions Karastan as an excellent option. Emphasizes the importance of maintenance and a good pad.
Shares positive experience with Smartstrand carpet but notes that different brands have mixed reviews.
Expresses dissatisfaction with triexta carpet after a year and regrets not going to a specialized carpet place.
Describes two triexta carpets from Home Depot, one holding up better in a lower traffic area, while the other matted down quickly and had a color discrepancy. Plans to replace the latter.
Shares positive experience with 100% Triexta carpet in the past and recently with 75% Triexta. Considers Triexta comparable to nylon but less expensive. Recommends Mohawk Smartstrand brand. Advises avoiding polyester unless for short-term use. Mentions using tight loop nylon carpets for high traffic areas and using entrance mats for soil prevention.

#7 Stain-Resistant carpets

nylon stain resistant carpet
Stain resistant carpet

What Type of Carpet Does Not Flatten?

Nobody wants a flat and lifeless carpet.

Here are some types of carpets that don’t flatten:

  1. Nylon: Nylon carpets, with their inherent resilience, tend to bounce back and resist flattening. They retain their texture and shape even in high-traffic areas, ensuring a long-lasting visual appeal.
  2. Wool: Wool carpets, thanks to their natural springiness, have the ability to recover their shape after being compressed. Their fibers have a natural elasticity that helps the carpet maintain its original form.
  3. Frieze: Frieze carpets, with their twisted and crimped fibers, are excellent at hiding footprints and vacuum marks. The textured surface helps the carpet maintain a fluffy appearance, even in areas with heavy use.


What are the three types of carpet?

The three types of carpet commonly discussed are nylon, wool, and polyester. These fibers offer different characteristics and benefits, allowing homeowners to choose the carpet that best suits their needs.

What is triexta carpet?

Triexta carpet is a relatively new fiber in the carpet industry. It combines the best qualities of other fibers, such as durability, stain resistance, and softness. Triexta carpets are an excellent choice for those seeking a balance between performance and comfort.

How can I maintain the cleanliness of my carpet?

Regular vacuuming, immediate spot cleaning of spills, and professional deep cleaning can help maintain the cleanliness of your carpet. Additionally, choosing a stain-resistant carpet fiber, such as nylon or triexta, can make cleaning easier and prevent stains from setting in.

How do I prevent my carpet from flattening?

To prevent carpet flattening, choose resilient fibers like nylon or wool. Additionally, using furniture coasters or rotating heavy items periodically can help distribute the weight and prevent specific areas from flattening over time. Regular vacuuming can also help lift the fibers and maintain their shape.


In conclusion, Reddit serves as an invaluable resource for those seeking carpet recommendations and insights.

From the elegance of wool to the durability of triexta, there are endless options to explore. By considering the best carpet Reddit has to offer and taking into account factors such as durability, softness, cleanliness, and luxury, you can make an informed decision that aligns with your preferences and lifestyle.

Remember, when it comes to finding the perfect carpet, Reddit’s recommendations can guide you toward the best options available.

Take advantage of the collective wisdom and experiences shared by the Reddit community to make an informed decision that brings both beauty and practicality to your home.

About the Author

author pic

Helga is writing here all about carpets and rugs in our lives. She puts her own expertise of an ordinary human being, looks for challenges we all face in the world of carpets, does research, and puts the most valuable parts of information together to help homeowners and business owners maintain clean, fresh, and inviting spaces. We believe that a well-maintained carpet not only enhances the aesthetics of a room but also contributes to a healthier living or working environment.

1 thought on “Best Carpet Reddit Recommendations: Top 7 Picks”

Comments are closed.