Is Carpet Out of Style? [Reddit Opinions]

Carpet has been a staple in the flooring industry for decades. It has been loved for its warmth, comfort, and noise-reducing qualities. However, as modern homes continue to embrace minimalist designs and open floor plans, …

Is Carpet Out of Style?

Carpet has been a staple in the flooring industry for decades. It has been loved for its warmth, comfort, and noise-reducing qualities. However, as modern homes continue to embrace minimalist designs and open floor plans, the popularity of carpets seems to be fading away. So, is carpet out of style?

This question is ongoing on the Internet regularly as it’s about the comfort and visual aesthetics in our home space. Those who argue that carpet is no longer fashionable believe that it can make a room feel outdated and stuffy.

Many people consider hardwood floors or tiles to be more stylish and modern flooring options. Others argue that carpet never really goes out of style and is still a popular choice in many homes.

Some even believe that certain styles of carpet can add a sense of coziness and sophistication to a space.

On one hand, there are individuals who believe that it should be relegated to the past because it doesn’t fit into modern aesthetics. On the other hand, there are individuals who cherish the softness and warmth it provides in their homes regardless of what’s fashionable at any given time.

So which side is right? Let’s take a closer look at some pros and cons associated with having carpets in your home to help you decide for yourself!

Therefore we will use the help of one of the biggest audiences on the Internet – the Reddit community.

We have researched a dozen of related threads and here is what people think and share about whether is carpet out of style or not.

What Are the Pros and Cons of Carpets?

Carpet has been a popular flooring choice for many homes due to its softness, warmth, and insulation properties. It can also serve as a visually pleasing addition to any room in the house.

However, despite its popularity, carpet has its disadvantages as well. In this section, we will weigh in on the pros and cons of having carpet in your home.

Advantages of Having Carpet

The most significant advantage of having a carpet is that it provides a comfortable walking surface that is warm and soft underfoot. This makes it ideal for bedrooms or living rooms where people spend most of their time relaxing or entertaining guests.

Additionally, carpets provide insulation against noise pollution by absorbing sound waves that would otherwise bounce off hard surfaces like hardwood or tile floors.

Carpet also comes in various styles and colors which makes it easier to match with any interior decor theme.

It can be used to make a statement or blend into the background depending on how you want your room to look.

Furthermore, carpets are relatively affordable compared to other flooring materials such as hardwood which means you can have beautiful floors without breaking the bank.

Here are more main theses and opinions people share on the advantages of carpets and carpeting:

What are the advantages of carpets according to Reddit comments?

Comfortable underfootCarpet provides a cozy and comfortable surface to walk on, especially in bedrooms and second-floor areas.
Sound insulationCarpets can help dampen noise, making them suitable for bedrooms and other areas where sound reduction is desired.
WarmthIn certain climates, carpets can provide insulation and make the room feel warmer.
Luxurious feelHigh-quality carpets with luxurious padding can create a luxurious and comfortable experience.
Personal preferenceChoosing carpeting is a matter of personal preference, allowing individuals to make their living space the way they want it.
Protection against fallsCarpet can reduce the risk of slips and provide some padding in case of a fall, making it beneficial for older people.
Pet-friendlyPets, especially older ones, may find carpeting more comfortable to walk and lie on.
Easy maintenanceRegular vacuuming and occasional deep cleaning can keep carpets clean, and newer carpet models are resistant to stains and crushing.
FlexibilityResidential carpet tiles offer the flexibility to remove and replace individual tiles if stains occur.
Potential resale valueWhile personal preference should take precedence, opting for flooring with higher resale value may be worth considering if planning to sell the house within a few years.
Provides a cozy feeling (upstairs)
Nice to wake up and stand on carpet instead of a cold floor
Carpet is still a very popular choice. People choose it because it is normal and boring, and it has qualities that people like.
Carpets are warmer and provide a more homely feel, favored by homeowners
Carpet is safest on stairs compared to other flooring options.
Proper care can help maintain carpets and extend their lifespan.
They can be more suitable for bedrooms and areas where people like to sit or lie down.
Carpeted floors can be preferred by individuals with allergies as they can trap dust and allergens, preventing them from circulating in the air.
Easy to train kids to keep food and drinks in the kitchenIt is possible to train kids to follow the rule of not taking food and drinks outside the kitchen to prevent carpet stains.
Cozy for curling up on the couch and watching moviesCarpet adds coziness and comfort, allowing people to curl up on the couch and enjoy activities like watching movies.
Underfloor heating is not compatible with carpetsUnderfloor heating is becoming popular, but it is not compatible with carpets.
Hardwood floors with area rugs can cause safety concernsHardwood floors with area rugs can be hazardous, as they can cause people to trip and fall.
Carpet hides variances in the levelness of the floorCarpet is effective at hiding variances in the levelness of the floor, providing a more even and consistent appearance.
Different flooring types have different usesThe carpet is effective at hiding variances in the levelness of the floor, providing a more even and consistent appearance.

Disadvantages of Having Carpet

One major disadvantage of having carpet is that it requires more maintenance than other types of flooring such as hardwood or tile. Carpets tend to accumulate dirt and stains easily which can be difficult to clean up if left unattended for long periods.

Furthermore, spills can lead to permanent staining which may require costly repairs or replacement.

Carpets are also known for harboring allergens such as dust mites which may trigger allergies or asthma attacks.

This makes it less suitable for people with respiratory problems who may not be able to tolerate the air quality in spaces with carpets. While carpet has its benefits, it also has some drawbacks that should be considered before deciding whether to install it in your home.

Here are further detailed opinions on carpet disadvantages shared by the Reddit community.

Filth and allergensCarpets can accumulate dirt, dust, and allergens over time, making them less suitable for people with allergies.
Stains and wearCarpets are more prone to staining and wear compared to other types of flooring, requiring regular maintenance and eventual replacement.
Odor retentionHouses with pets may develop an odor due to pets’ accidents, which can be absorbed by carpets.
Lower perceived valueHard surface floors are generally considered to add more value to a home compared to carpets.
Cleaning challengesDeep cleaning carpets can be more challenging compared to hard floors, requiring specialized equipment and professional cleaning services.
Allergy concernsCarpeting can be a concern for individuals with allergies, as they can trap allergens and make them difficult to remove completely.
Replacement disruptionReplacing carpets can cause disruption and inconvenience every few years when installers take over the home.
Cheaper to have a wood floor and get the tenant to buy a rug
One problem with carpeting is that people don’t replace it frequently enough.
They can be prone to stains and spills, which may require extra effort to clean.
Carpets may not be suitable for rooms with high traffic, pets, or young children, as they can be more difficult to clean in these cases.
Dust and dirt can accumulate underneath carpets, especially if not regularly cleaned.
Carpet is suitable for households without pets or children.Carpet is great if you don’t have kids or pets.
Environmental and health concernsCertain types of carpeting materials can release chemicals and fibers that may pose risks, especially for young children, pets, or individuals with compromised immune systems.
Limited design optionsCarpets may limit design choices and may not be suitable for all interior styles.
Hygiene concernsCarpets in bathrooms can be unhygienic and prone to mold and moisture-related issues.

Current Trends in Flooring

From Carpet to Hardwood, Vinyl, and Tile

Gone are the days when carpet was the only flooring option for homeowners. Today’s flooring industry is booming with a wide variety of options that cater to different lifestyles and design preferences.

Among the most popular options are hardwood, vinyl, and tile.


Hardwood has always been a classic choice for those looking for durability and elegance.

It adds warmth to any room with its natural grain patterns and rich colors. It is now considered one of the most popular flooring options in the market today due to its timeless appeal.


Vinyl, on the other hand, is fast becoming a preferred option because of its versatility and affordability. It can mimic almost any type of material from wood to stone while being highly resistant to water damage, making it ideal for kitchens or bathrooms.


Tile is another popular option that comes in an array of textures, sizes, colors, and finishes. It is perfect for high-traffic areas due to its durability while also being easy to maintain.

The Appeal of Hard Flooring Over Carpet

One reason why hard flooring options like hardwood, vinyl and tile are gaining popularity over carpet is their ease of maintenance.

Unlike carpets which require regular vacuuming or even professional cleaning every so often – these hard floors can last longer without much hassle.

Additionally, such floorings provide better air quality as they do not harbor dust mites or allergens – something that carpets are notorious for doing if not maintained properly.

carpet and hardwood flooring
Carpet and hardwood flooring; Google Images caption

Another factor that makes hard floors more appealing than carpet is their aesthetic appeal as they offer endless design possibilities with various colors an patterns.

All things considered; it’s obvious why carpet may have lost some ground in today’s market where people want low maintenance homes without sacrificing style or function.

Carpet Styles That Are Still Popular Today

Despite the growing trend towards hard flooring, there are still carpet styles that remain fashionable in modern interiors.

One popular style is plush carpet with neutral colors or patterns. These carpets have a soft texture and come in a variety of colors such as beige, gray, and cream, which can complement any interior design scheme.

plush carpet
Plush carpet

They are perfect for those who want to create a relaxing and cozy atmosphere in their homes.

Another popular style is patterned carpet. These carpets have intricate designs that can add visual interest to any room. They come in various patterns such as floral, geometric, and abstract designs.

Patterned carpets are ideal for those who want to make a bold statement in their home’s interior design while simultaneously enjoying the comfort of carpeting.

Patterned carpets
Patterned carpets

Additionally, textured carpets are also gaining popularity today.

These carpets have varying pile heights that add depth and dimension to any room. Textured carpets come in different styles such as cut pile, loop pile, or a combination of both.

They are great for high-traffic areas because they hide footprints and vacuum marks very well.

textured carpets
Textured carpets

Overall, there are many carpet styles that remain stylish today despite the trend towards hard flooring options like tile or hardwood floors.

Carpet adds warmth and texture to any space while also providing comfort underfoot like no other option can do.

It’s all down to personal preference when it comes to choosing between hard flooring or carpeting for your home – but thankfully there is still plenty of choice available if you decide you would prefer an inviting plush surface underfoot!

Factors That Affect Carpet’s Style Status

The Role of Location

One of the biggest factors that can affect whether or not carpet is considered stylish is the location of a home. In colder climates where temperatures can drop below freezing, plush carpeting can provide much-needed insulation and warmth.

In these areas, people may be more likely to view carpet as a cozy and comfortable flooring option.

However, in warmer climates where temperatures are consistently high, carpeting may be seen as outdated and impractical.

Location can also impact the type of carpet that is popular in certain areas. For example, Berber carpets may be more common in desert regions due to their durability and ability to withstand sand and dirt that can easily get tracked into homes.

Lifestyle Factors

Another important factor that can impact whether or not someone views carpet as fashionable is their lifestyle.

Families with young children or pets may prefer hardwood or tile floors due to their ease of cleaning and resistance to stains. On the other hand, older couples or those without children may value the comfort and noise-reducing qualities of carpets more highly.

Additionally, individuals who entertain frequently or host large gatherings may prefer hard floors for their ease of cleaning after parties.

Conversely, those who prioritize comfort above all else might choose plush carpets that feel soft underfoot.

Personal Preferences

Ultimately, is it better to have carpet or not, or shortly speaking the personal preferences play a huge role in determining whether someone considers carpet to be out of style or not. Some people simply prefer the look and feel of carpets over other flooring options like hardwoods or vinyl.

Reddit discussions on this topic illustrate how opinions on this issue vary widely based on individual preferences.

For instance, some users argue that plush carpets with neutral tones are always fashionable because they complement any decor style while others argue for bold patterns or vibrant colors as modern styles.

Location, lifestyle factors, and personal preferences can all influence whether or not someone views carpet as stylish.

Ultimately, it is up to individual homeowners to determine whether carpet is the right choice for their home based on these factors and their own tastes.


Does Carpet Devalue Your Home?

Carpet does not necessarily devalue your home, as its impact on home value can vary depending on factors such as quality, style, and maintenance.

A well-maintained and high-quality carpet can enhance the comfort and aesthetics of a home, potentially increasing its appeal to buyers.

However, some buyers may have personal preferences for other flooring options like hardwood or tile.

Ultimately, the value of your home is determined by a combination of factors, including location, overall condition, and market demand. So, while carpet may not be a deal-breaker, it’s important to consider factors that appeal to potential buyers in your specific real estate market if you plan to sell your house or apparment.


After examining the pros and cons of carpet, current flooring trends, popular carpet styles, and factors that affect its style status, it’s clear that the question of whether or not carpet is out of style is complex and subjective.

While some people may view carpet as outdated, there are still many instances where it can be a great choice for a home.

One thing to keep in mind when considering carpet is that personal preference plays a big role in determining whether or not it’s stylish.

Some people simply love the look and feel of soft carpets underfoot, while others prefer the sleek appearance of hard flooring options like hardwood or tile.

Additionally, factors such as location and lifestyle can greatly influence someone’s opinion on whether or not carpet is fashionable.

If you’re trying to decide whether or not to install carpet in your home, it’s important to weigh all the relevant factors before making a decision. Consider your budget, design preferences, lifestyle needs (e.g., do you have pets? Do you entertain frequently?), and other relevant factors when making your decision.

Ultimately, the choice between different flooring options will depend on what works best for you and your family.

It’s worth noting that even if some people view carpet as out of style right now, trends are always changing.

Who knows – perhaps in a few years’ time we’ll see a resurgence of plush carpets in bold patterns!

The bottom line is that when it comes to interior design choices like this one, there are no hard and fast rules – only personal preferences and practical considerations.

So if you’re considering installing carpet in your home but are worried about its style status – don’t worry too much. Choose what feels right for you and your family right now – after all, at the end of the day it’s your home and you should feel comfortable there above all else.

About the Author

author pic

Helga is writing here all about carpets and rugs in our lives. She puts her own expertise of an ordinary human being, looks for challenges we all face in the world of carpets, does research, and puts the most valuable parts of information together to help homeowners and business owners maintain clean, fresh, and inviting spaces. We believe that a well-maintained carpet not only enhances the aesthetics of a room but also contributes to a healthier living or working environment.

1 thought on “Is Carpet Out of Style? [Reddit Opinions]”

Comments are closed.