Bissell vs Rug Doctor Reddit [Recommendations]

If you’ve ever tried to tackle the task of cleaning your carpets, you probably know that choosing the right carpet cleaner can make a world of difference. Two popular names that often come up in …

Bissell vs Rug Doctor Reddit

If you’ve ever tried to tackle the task of cleaning your carpets, you probably know that choosing the right carpet cleaner can make a world of difference.

Two popular names that often come up in this context are Bissell and Rug Doctor. Both are renowned brands in the carpet cleaning industry, but what sets them apart?

In this blog post, we’ll delve into the key differences between Bissell and Rug Doctor, taking an analytical perspective to help you make an informed decision for your carpet cleaning needs.

What is the difference between a Bissell and a Rug Doctor?

At first glance, both Bissell and Rug Doctor offer similar promises of providing a thorough carpet cleaning experience. However, they differ in several aspects that can significantly impact your cleaning results.

Bissell – The Carpet Cleaner for Everyday Use

Bissell carpet cleaners are designed with convenience in mind.

They are more compact and lightweight, making them easier to maneuver around your home. If you have pets or kids and need to clean up small spills and stains regularly, a Bissell cleaner might be the ideal choice. It’s perfect for quick touch-ups and keeping your carpets looking fresh on a day-to-day basis.

Bissell carpet cleaners come in various models, catering to different cleaning needs. Their portable spot cleaners, like the Bissell Little Green ProHeat, are great for handling localized stains or cleaning upholstery.

Bissell Little Green ProHeat

For larger areas, the Bissell ProHeat 2X Revolution offers powerful suction and a deep cleaning system, making it suitable for whole-room carpet cleaning.

One notable advantage of Bissell is the availability of its cleaning solutions and accessories. Bissell offers a wide range of specially formulated carpet cleaning solutions to target different types of stains and odors.

This flexibility allows you to customize your cleaning process and achieve optimal results.

Rug Doctor – The Heavy-Duty Cleaning Specialist

On the other hand, Rug Doctor is known for its heavy-duty performance.

It’s the go-to choice for deep cleaning and tackling stubborn stains and embedded dirt. If your carpets have endured years of heavy foot traffic or you want a comprehensive deep clean periodically, the Rug Doctor is up for the challenge. Its larger tanks and powerful suction are designed to extract dirt and grime effectively.

Rug Doctor offers rental options for their carpet cleaners, allowing you to access professional-grade cleaning power without the expense of owning a machine.

Their rental machines are available in various sizes, including the classic Rug Doctor Deep Carpet Cleaner and the more compact Rug Doctor FlexClean. These rental options make Rug Doctor a popular choice for spring cleaning, moving out, or hosting special events at home.

Rug Doctor Deep Carpet Cleaner

The effectiveness of Rug Doctor lies in its hot water extraction cleaning method. This process involves injecting hot water and cleaning solution into the carpet while simultaneously extracting it along with the loosened dirt and stains.

The result is a thorough and deep clean that leaves your carpets looking rejuvenated.

Does a Rug Doctor have good suction?

One of the most critical factors in a carpet cleaner’s performance is its suction power. A carpet cleaner with weak suction won’t be able to lift dirt and water effectively, leaving your carpets damp and prone to mold and mildew growth.

When it comes to suction power, Rug Doctor takes the lead.

Its robust suction capability ensures that it removes more water and dirt from your carpets, resulting in a faster drying time. This means you can get back to enjoying your freshly cleaned carpets sooner.

Rug Doctor’s machines feature powerful motors and high water-lift technology, which allows them to extract more moisture during the cleaning process.

As a result, your carpets dry faster and are less likely to suffer from water damage.

The high suction power of Rug Doctor machines also contributes to their ability to remove deeply embedded dirt and tough stains. Whether it’s pet accidents, wine spills, or years of accumulated grime, Rug Doctor’s powerful suction can handle the toughest cleaning challenges.

Is the Bissell carpet cleaner worth it?

The value of any cleaning appliance lies in its ability to deliver on its promises.

With Bissell carpet cleaners, you get a reliable and affordable option for everyday cleaning needs. If you have a busy household with small spills and stains that require immediate attention, a Bissell cleaner will prove its worth time and again.

Bissell’s popularity can be attributed to its user-friendly features and ease of use. Most Bissell models come with user-friendly controls and straightforward setup procedures, allowing you to start cleaning your carpets without any hassle.

Moreover, Bissell’s extensive range of models ensures that you can find one that fits your budget and requirements. Whether you need a compact spot cleaner or a full-sized carpet cleaner, Bissell has got you covered.

The affordability of Bissell machines, along with their satisfactory performance, makes them a popular choice for homeowners and renters alike.

Bissell vs Rug Doctor

Another advantage of investing in a Bissell carpet cleaner is the convenience of having a cleaner available at your disposal whenever you need it.

Instead of waiting for an appointment or renting a machine, having a Bissell carpet cleaner on hand allows you to address spills and stains as soon as they occur.

The accessibility of Bissell’s cleaning solutions also contributes to the brand’s appeal. Bissell offers a variety of cleaning formulas for different purposes, such as pet stain removers, deep cleaning solutions, and eco-friendly options.

This diversity empowers users to select the most suitable cleaning solution based on their specific needs.

Bissell vs Rug Doctor Reddit Recommendations and Advice

Online communities like Reddit can be treasure troves of valuable advice from real users who have hands-on experience with these carpet cleaners.

It’s essential to consider multiple perspectives to get a well-rounded view.

Here are some recommendations from Reddit users regarding Bissell vs. Rug Doctor:

AspectBissellRug Doctor
Water TemperatureSome users reported issues with cheap hose deforming and breaking when using very hot water for extraction.No specific comments about water temperature limitations.
FunctionalitySome users find the agitating brush on Bissell models dependent on air suction and not as effective.Rug Doctor’s agitating brush does a decent job, not dependent on air suction.
Roots & InnovationRug Doctor is known for its roots in industrial-grade carpet cleaning and being an innovator in the industry.Bissell has not been mentioned as an innovator in the industry.
PriceRug Doctor costs around $450 on Amazon.Bissell models vary in price, but there are affordable options available.
EffectivenessProfessional carpet cleaning equipment is generally more effective but comes at a higher cost.While not as powerful as professional equipment, home machines like Bissell can still do a decent job.
ConvenienceBuying a home machine allows for convenient spot cleaning and regular maintenance without the need for rental.Renting a machine might be cheaper for occasional use, but the cost can add up over time.
Cleaning QualityProfessional equipment offers superior cleaning quality but comes at a higher price.Home machines like Bissell can still provide good cleaning results for regular maintenance.
Noise LevelSome users report loud noise in some Bissell models.No specific comments about noise level for Rug Doctor.
Professional ScamsSome users report upselling and high costs associated with professional carpet cleaning services.Individual experiences vary, and some had positive experiences with professional carpet cleaners.
Water Tank SizeRug Doctor’s water tank is mentioned as being smaller and harder to fill/clean.No specific comments about Bissell’s water tank size or ease of use.

Keep in mind that individual experiences may vary, and it’s essential to consider your specific needs and preferences when choosing between Bissell and Rug Doctor.

How long does it take for carpet to dry after using Bissell?

The drying time after carpet cleaning is crucial, as excessive moisture can lead to mold and mildew growth.

With Bissell carpet cleaners, the drying time typically ranges from 2 to 6 hours, depending on the model and the carpet’s thickness. Proper ventilation and using fans can expedite the drying process.

During the cleaning process, Bissell machines use a combination of hot water and cleaning solution to dissolve and lift dirt and stains from the carpet fibers. The powerful suction of Bissell carpet cleaners effectively removes the water and cleaning solution along with the loosened dirt, leaving the carpet damp but not soaking wet.

Factors such as humidity, airflow, and carpet type can influence the drying time. In drier climates with good air circulation, the carpets are likely to dry faster.

Conversely, in humid environments or rooms with poor ventilation, the drying process may take longer.

To speed up the drying process, you can open windows and doors to let fresh air in and use fans to improve airflow.

It’s also advisable to avoid walking on damp carpets until they are completely dry to prevent new dirt from settling into the fibers.

Do I need to vacuum before using BISSELL carpet cleaner?

Yes, it’s essential to vacuum your carpets before using any carpet cleaner, including Bissell.

Vacuuming removes loose dirt, debris, and pet hair from the carpet’s surface, allowing the carpet cleaner to focus on deep cleaning. This ensures more effective results and prolongs the life of your carpet cleaner.

Vacuuming before carpet cleaning helps the carpet cleaner to work more efficiently. By removing surface dirt and debris, the carpet cleaner can focus on tackling the deeper, embedded dirt and stains that vacuuming alone cannot eliminate.

Additionally, vacuuming before carpet cleaning prevents the carpet cleaner’s brushes and nozzles from getting clogged with loose dirt and debris. This allows the machine to maintain its suction power and ensures a smoother cleaning process.

When vacuuming before using a Bissell carpet cleaner, pay attention to high-traffic areas, spots with visible stains, and areas where pets frequently stay.

Removing as much loose dirt and debris as possible will enhance the effectiveness of the carpet cleaner and lead to better cleaning results.

Is Rug Doctor a steam cleaner or shampooer?

Rug Doctor is primarily a hot water extraction cleaner, often referred to as a carpet shampooer.

It uses a combination of hot water and cleaning solution to deep clean carpets by breaking down dirt and stains. While some models may generate steam during the cleaning process, the main cleaning method is hot water extraction.

Hot water extraction is a popular and effective method used by professional carpet cleaners to remove deeply embedded dirt, stains, and odors from carpets.

In the case of Rug Doctor, the machine sprays hot water and cleaning solution onto the carpet, agitates the fibers to dislodge dirt, and then extracts the dirty water and solution back into the machine’s waste tank.

The term “steam cleaner” is often associated with carpet cleaning machines that use steam to clean carpets.

While some carpet cleaners claim to be steam cleaners, they typically use hot water and not actual steam. Steam cleaning, in the true sense, involves using water vapor at extremely high temperatures, which can damage certain carpet fibers and cause shrinkage.

Rug Doctor’s hot water extraction method ensures a thorough cleaning process that reaches deep into the carpet fibers, resulting in a more effective and comprehensive clean compared to regular vacuuming or surface cleaning methods.

Can you use Bissell carpet cleaner in a Rug Doctor?

While it might be tempting to mix and match cleaning solutions and appliances, it’s essential to follow the manufacturer’s guidelines.

In many cases, Bissell and Rug Doctor have different cleaning solutions and machines designed for specific purposes. Using a Bissell carpet cleaner solution in a Rug Doctor might not yield the desired results and could potentially damage the machine.

In general, you can use Bissell carpet cleaner in a Rug Doctor if the solution meets all the needed characteristics of your Rug Doctor.

Each brand formulates its cleaning solutions with specific ingredients and concentrations to work optimally with its carpet cleaner’s design. Bissell’s cleaning solutions are formulated to complement the features and functionalities of Bissell carpet cleaners, while Rug Doctor’s solutions are designed for their hot water extraction machines.

Using a Bissell solution in a Rug Doctor machine might result in excess foam or insufficient cleaning power, affecting the machine’s performance. It could also lead to clogging or damage to the machine’s internal components.

Similarly, using a Rug Doctor solution in a Bissell carpet cleaner might not produce the desired level of cleaning, and the different chemical compositions could lead to adverse effects on the machine.

To ensure the best cleaning results and to maintain the longevity of your carpet cleaner, always follow the manufacturer’s guidelines and use the recommended cleaning solutions for your specific machine.

List of Key Differences between Bissell and Rug Doctor:

  1. Design and Size:
    • Bissell: Compact and lightweight, suitable for everyday use and small spills.
    • Rug Doctor: Larger and heavier, built for heavy-duty deep cleaning and tackling stubborn stains.
  2. Suction Power:
    • Bissell: Good suction for everyday cleaning needs.
    • Rug Doctor: Excellent suction for a thorough and faster drying experience.
  3. Use Cases:
    • Bissell: Ideal for regular touch-ups and maintaining carpet appearance.
    • Rug Doctor: Perfect for periodic deep cleaning and reviving heavily soiled carpets.
  4. Drying Time:
    • Bissell: Carpets typically dry within 2 to 6 hours.
    • Rug Doctor: Provides faster drying times due to its powerful suction.
  5. Cleaning Method:
    • Bissell: Uses hot water and cleaning solution for deep cleaning.
    • Rug Doctor: Primarily utilizes hot water extraction as a carpet shampooer.

Pros and Cons: Bissell vs. Rug Doctor



  • Compact and lightweight design.
  • Easy to use and maneuver.
  • Affordable and budget-friendly.
  • Wide range of models and cleaning solutions.
  • Ideal for regular maintenance and spot cleaning.


  • May not be as effective for deep cleaning heavy stains.
  • Drying time can vary depending on the model and carpet type.

Rug Doctor:


  • Powerful suction for deep and thorough cleaning.
  • Effective for heavy-duty and deep cleaning tasks.
  • Rental options available for occasional use.
  • Faster drying times.
  • Suitable for high-traffic areas and heavily soiled carpets.


  • Larger and heavier, may be less convenient to use.
  • Rental costs can add up for frequent deep cleaning.
  • Some models may be noisy during operation.


In conclusion, the choice between Bissell and Rug Doctor depends on your specific carpet cleaning needs. If you require a reliable and budget-friendly option for everyday use and small spills, Bissell is the way to go.

However, if you need a heavy-duty cleaner for periodic deep cleaning and tackling tough stains, Rug Doctor is the clear winner.

When considering which brand to choose, factors such as the frequency of use, the level of soiling in your carpets, and your budget should be taken into account. Bissell carpet cleaners are excellent for regular maintenance and quick clean-ups, making them perfect for busy households with pets and kids.

On the other hand, Rug Doctor is ideal for comprehensive deep cleaning and reviving heavily soiled carpets, making it a top choice for those seeking professional-grade results.

Remember to consider user recommendations from platforms like Reddit, as they offer valuable insights from real users who have experienced the performance of these machines firsthand.

Ultimately, whether you choose Bissell or Rug Doctor, regular carpet maintenance and cleaning are essential to prolonging the life and appearance of your carpets.

Always follow the manufacturer’s guidelines for cleaning solutions and maintenance to ensure optimal performance and longevity for your chosen carpet cleaner.

We hope this comprehensive guide has helped you gain a deeper understanding of the differences between Bissell and Rug Doctor, empowering you to make the best decision for your carpet cleaning needs. Happy cleaning!

About the Author

author pic

Helga is writing here all about carpets and rugs in our lives. She puts her own expertise of an ordinary human being, looks for challenges we all face in the world of carpets, does research, and puts the most valuable parts of information together to help homeowners and business owners maintain clean, fresh, and inviting spaces. We believe that a well-maintained carpet not only enhances the aesthetics of a room but also contributes to a healthier living or working environment.

3 thoughts on “Bissell vs Rug Doctor Reddit [Recommendations]”

Comments are closed.