Should I Install Carpet or Hardwood in Living Room? [Dilemma]

Are you facing a flooring dilemma for your living room “carpet or hardwood in living room”? Choosing between carpet and hardwood floors can be a tough decision to make. After all, the living room is …

carpet or hardwood in living room

Are you facing a flooring dilemma for your living room “carpet or hardwood in living room”? Choosing between carpet and hardwood floors can be a tough decision to make.

After all, the living room is where you spend quality time with family and friends, and you want it to be comfortable, stylish, and practical.

In this blog post, we’ll delve into the pros and cons of carpet and hardwood floors in the living room. By the end, you’ll have a better understanding of which option suits your needs and preferences.

Do People Still Put Carpet in Their Living Room?

In the past, it was common to find wall-to-wall carpeting in living rooms. However, as interior design trends have evolved, many homeowners have opted for alternative flooring options such as hardwood.

Despite this shift, carpet still holds its ground in many living rooms. The softness and warmth it provides can create a cozy and inviting atmosphere.

Why Do People Prefer Hardwood Floors Over Carpet?

Hardwood floors have gained popularity due to their timeless appeal and durability. They offer a sleek and sophisticated look that complements various interior styles, from traditional to contemporary.

Hardwood is also known for its longevity, with proper care and maintenance, it can last for decades.

Furthermore, hardwood floors are easy to clean, making them a practical choice for busy households.

hardwood flooring
Hard flooring types; Google Images caption

What Is Healthier: Carpet or Hardwood Floors?

When it comes to health considerations, the debate between carpet and hardwood floors continues.

Carpets can trap dust, allergens, and pet dander, which can affect indoor air quality, especially for individuals with allergies or respiratory issues.

Regular vacuuming and professional cleaning can help mitigate these concerns.

On the other hand, hardwood floors are hypoallergenic and less likely to harbor allergens. They offer a cleaner and healthier living environment, particularly for those with sensitivities.

Is It Better to Have Carpet or Hardwood Floors in the Living Room?

Is it better to have carpet or hardwood in living room – this is the question.

Choosing between carpet and hardwood floors for your living room depends on various factors.

Let’s weigh the pros and cons:

Carpet in Living Room

Pros: Why do people prefer carpet over hardwood?

  • Comfort: The carpet provides a soft and cushioned surface, making it ideal for lounging and relaxation.
  • Insulation: It acts as an insulator, keeping the room warm and reducing noise levels.
  • Design Versatility: With a wide range of colors, patterns, and textures, carpets offer endless design possibilities.

Cons: What is the disadvantage of a carpeted floor in the living room?

  • Maintenance: Carpets require regular cleaning and may be more susceptible to staining and wear.
  • Allergens and Dust: Carpets can harbor allergens, dust, and pet hair, requiring more attention to cleanliness.
  • Limited Lifespan: Over time, carpets may show signs of wear and tear, requiring replacement or refurbishment.

Hardwood Floors in Living Room

Pros: Why do people like hardwood floors?

  • Durability: Hardwood floors are known for their longevity and ability to withstand high-traffic areas.
  • Easy Maintenance: Is hardwood easier to clean than carpet? Yes, regular sweeping and occasional polishing is typically sufficient to keep hardwood floors looking pristine.
  • Timeless Aesthetics: Hardwood floors add a touch of elegance and sophistication to any living room.


  • Cost: Hardwood floors can be more expensive to install compared to carpeting.
  • Cold and Noise: They can be colder underfoot, and without proper insulation, may transmit sound more easily.
  • Susceptibility to Scratches: Hardwood floors may require refinishing or repair if they become scratched or damaged.

Considering these factors, the choice between carpet and hardwood floors ultimately depends on your personal preferences, lifestyle, and budget.

Carpet and Wood Flooring Combinations

A popular trend in interior design is the combination of carpet and wood flooring within the same living space.

This approach allows you to enjoy the benefits of both materials while creating visual interest and defining different areas within the room.

For example, you might consider having hardwood floors near the entrance and in high-traffic areas, while incorporating a plush carpet in the seating area for added comfort and coziness.

Do people put carpet over hardwood?

Yes, some people choose to put carpet over hardwood floors.

carpet and wood flooring combinations
Сarpet and wood flooring combinations; Google Images caption

This can be done for a variety of reasons, depending on personal preferences and needs. Here are a few common scenarios where people opt to have carpet over hardwood:

  1. Comfort and Warmth: Hardwood floors can sometimes feel cold, especially in colder climates. Adding a carpet on top, it provides an extra layer of insulation and comfort underfoot. This can make the living space cozier, particularly during the winter months.
  2. Noise Reduction: Hardwood floors can amplify sound and create an echo effect in a room. Adding carpet can help absorb and reduce noise, making the living space quieter and more acoustically pleasing. This can be especially beneficial for households with young children or in multi-level homes.
  3. Style and Design: Aesthetically, some individuals prefer the look of hardwood floors in certain areas of the room while using carpets to define specific spaces or add decorative elements. For example, placing an area rug over hardwood floors can serve as a focal point in the living room or highlight a seating area.
  4. Temporary or Rental Solutions: In rental properties or situations where the homeowner may not want to make permanent changes, placing a carpet over hardwood floors can be a convenient solution. It allows for personalization and the ability to remove the carpet when needed without affecting the original flooring.

It’s important to note that when placing a carpet over hardwood, it’s essential to use rug pads or non-slip mats to prevent the carpet from shifting or damaging the hardwood surface.

Additionally, regular cleaning and maintenance of both the carpet and hardwood floors should be carried out to ensure the longevity and cleanliness of the flooring combination.

Do you need a rug in a carpeted living room?

Or is it dumb to put a rug over carpet?

Whether or not you need a rug in a carpeted living room depends on personal preference and the specific aesthetic or functional goals you have for your space.

Here are a few considerations to help you decide:

  1. Style and Design: Adding a rug to a carpeted living room can enhance the overall design and add visual interest. It allows you to introduce different patterns, textures, or colors that complement your existing carpet or furniture.
  2. Definition of Spaces: In larger living rooms, a rug can be used to define different functional areas within the space. For example, you can place a rug under a seating arrangement to visually separate it from other areas, such as a dining area or a workspace.
  3. Protection and Maintenance: Placing a rug in high-traffic areas or underneath furniture can help protect the underlying carpet from wear and tear. It can also make cleaning and maintenance easier, as you can remove and clean the rug separately if needed.

Ultimately, the decision to add a rug to a carpeted living room is subjective.

rug on carpet in living room
Rug on carpet in living room; Google Images caption

Consider your personal style, comfort preferences, and the specific needs of your space to determine whether a rug would be a beneficial addition.

Carpet in Living Room: Yes or No

Carpeting is a popular flooring option for many homeowners, especially those who want to create a cozy and inviting atmosphere in their homes.

There are several benefits of carpeting that make it a great choice for living room flooring.

Firstly, the carpet is very comfortable underfoot, making it ideal for relaxing on the couch or playing with kids. It can also help to reduce noise levels in the room, creating a more peaceful environment.

Additionally, carpet is often more affordable than hardwood flooring options, making it an attractive choice for homeowners on a budget.

However, there are some drawbacks to choosing carpet flooring that you should consider before making your decision.

One of the main issues with carpets is that they can be difficult to clean and maintain properly.

Dirt and dust can easily get trapped in the fibers of the carpet which may require regular deep cleaning. They are also susceptible to staining if spills are not cleaned up immediately.

If you have pets or children who may cause spills or accidents regularly, you may want to consider another type of flooring instead.

Carpets can be allergenic as they trap dust mites and other irritants which could potentially cause respiratory problems over time – not good news for allergy sufferers!

When considering whether or not to install carpet in your living room it’s important to think about what you value most – comfort, affordability, or ease of maintenance.

By understanding both the pros and cons of this type of flooring material you’ll be better equipped to choose what works best for your personal preferences and lifestyle needs.

Carpet or Hardwood Reddit Advice

If you’re seeking advice and opinions from real people, Reddit can be a valuable resource. The r/HomeImprovement subreddit, in particular, offers a platform where homeowners and professionals discuss various flooring options, including carpet and hardwood.

Remember to consider multiple perspectives and experiences to make an informed decision.

We have made our research on Reddit about “Carpet or Hardwood Dilemma” and here are some main points people share:

Main Points
Hardwood is cleaner and increases home value.
Carpet is toxic, collects allergens, and has a shorter lifespan. Hardwoods are easy to clean and can be changed with area rugs.
Hardwood floors can take scratches, are sensitive to humidity changes, and may crack. Carpet has its advantages in certain rooms (e.g., noise control, coziness, playroom).
Sanding through hardwood floors is a lot of work. Refinishing is necessary every few years.
Original hardwood floors can last for many years if well-maintained. Carpet may last only around 10 years.
Some prefer vinyl flooring.
Wood floors with an area rug can provide comfort and avoid the cold.
Carpet is disgusting and collects dust.
Carpet removal from foreclosed homes reveals its unpleasantness.
Hardwood is preferable for pet owners.
Laminate floors can scratch easily, while carpet feels nice on the feet.
A combination of hardwood and carpet is used in various rooms for different purposes.
Carpet is cheaper and adds comfort in colder climates.
Carpet improves acoustics, but hardwood with an area rug can achieve the same effect.
Bamboo flooring is harder than hardwood, more environmentally friendly, and less prone to scratches.
Hardwood floors are durable but can make the house louder with noisy kids.
Carpet provides comfort and temperature benefits, especially in the living room and bedroom.
Sheet vinyl is a suitable option for kitchens due to its practicality.

Carpet vs. Wood Floors Cost

Cost is a significant factor to consider when deciding between carpet and hardwood floors.

Generally, carpet is the more budget-friendly option, with lower installation costs and a wide range of price points.

On the other hand, hardwood floors tend to be more expensive upfront, including installation expenses. However, hardwood floors may add value to your home in the long run and can be a worthwhile investment.

On average, the installation cost for hardwood floors typically ranges from $12 to $20 per square foot, whereas carpet installation generally falls in the range of $6 to $12 per square foot.

How much does it cost to remove carpet and install wood?

The average cost of labor to remove carpet and install wood flooring varies between $4.25 and $9.25 per square foot.

How to Choose Carpet for Living Room

When selecting carpet for your living room, keep the following factors in mind:

  1. Durability: Look for carpets designed to withstand high-traffic areas, ensuring they will maintain their appearance over time.
  2. Fiber Type: Consider the different carpet fiber options available, such as nylon, polyester, or wool, each with its unique characteristics.
  3. Color and Style: Choose a carpet color and style that complements your existing decor and personal taste.
  4. Texture: Determine the desired texture, whether you prefer a plush, looped, or patterned carpet.
  5. Maintenance: Consider the ease of cleaning and maintenance required for the carpet type you choose.

By considering these aspects, you can find the perfect carpet that meets both your functional and aesthetic needs.

Best Living Room Carpet

The best living room carpet is subjective and depends on individual preferences, style, and lifestyle.

However, some popular carpet choices for living rooms include:

  • Plush Carpets: Luxuriously soft and comfortable underfoot, plush carpets create a cozy atmosphere.
  • Berber Carpets: Durable and stain-resistant, Berber carpets are known for their looped pile construction.
  • Patterned Carpets: Adding visual interest, patterned carpets can enhance the overall design of your living room.
  • Luxury Carpets for Living Room: Luxury carpets often have exquisite designs, patterns, and textures that can enhance the overall visual appeal of your living room. They can add a touch of elegance, sophistication, and luxury to the space, elevating its aesthetic appeal. High-quality luxury carpets are often made from durable materials that are built to withstand heavy foot traffic and maintain their appearance over time.

Remember to select a carpet that complements your furniture, walls, and overall interior theme to create a harmonious space.

Plush Carpets

plush carpets
Plush carpets for living room

Berber Loop Carpets

berber loop carpet
Berber loop carpet

Patterned Carpets

patterned carpets
Patterned carpets for living room

Luxury Carpets

luxury carpets for living room
Patterned carpets for living room


Should you have the same flooring throughout your house?

While it’s not necessary to have the same flooring throughout your house, maintaining consistency can create a cohesive and visually appealing look.

However, different flooring options may be more practical for specific areas, such as using waterproof materials in bathrooms or easy-to-clean surfaces in kitchens.

Does replacing carpet with hardwood increase value?

Should I replace my carpet with hardwood to increase the value of my house?

In many cases, replacing carpet with hardwood floors can increase the value of your home.

Hardwood floors are considered an attractive feature and may be more appealing to potential buyers, especially if they are well-maintained and suit the overall aesthetic of the property.

What rooms should not have carpet?

So, in what room is carpeting a poor choice?

Rooms that are prone to moisture, such as bathrooms and kitchens, are generally not suitable for carpeting due to the risk of water damage and hygiene concerns.

Additionally, high-traffic areas where dirt and stains are more likely, such as entryways and hallways, may be better suited for hard surfaces that are easier to clean and maintain.

What flooring is best for the living room?

The best flooring for the living room depends on your preferences and lifestyle. Hardwood floors offer a timeless and elegant look, while carpets provide warmth and comfort.

Other options, such as laminate, vinyl, or tile, can also be suitable based on your design preferences and specific needs.

In conclusion, the decision between carpet and hardwood floors for your living room should take into account factors such as comfort, maintenance, cost, and overall aesthetics.

By carefully considering your lifestyle and preferences, you can choose the flooring option that best suits your needs and creates a welcoming and stylish living space.

About the Author

author pic

Helga is writing here all about carpets and rugs in our lives. She puts her own expertise of an ordinary human being, looks for challenges we all face in the world of carpets, does research, and puts the most valuable parts of information together to help homeowners and business owners maintain clean, fresh, and inviting spaces. We believe that a well-maintained carpet not only enhances the aesthetics of a room but also contributes to a healthier living or working environment.

1 thought on “Should I Install Carpet or Hardwood in Living Room? [Dilemma]”

Comments are closed.